In a recent World of Fine Wine article, Rod Phillips argues that declining wine consumption reflects a broad cultural shift that is responding to economic precarity. Younger adults worry about health and careers prospects. They, have less money for discretionary purchases like wine, and research shows they are spending less time with friends compared to earlier generations, thus undermining one of the conditions that make wine drinking attractive. Drinking alone just isn’t much fun. Social life, he reports, is moving toward earlier meals and daytime gatherings where alcohol plays a smaller role. Combined with smaller younger generations when compared to boomers who are aging out of the wine market, these changes lead Phillips to expect a prolonged decline that better marketing can do little to reverse.
His account is persuasive. But some of the changes he describes may have a common source that complicates his forecast.
Several years ago, writing about the food revolution, I used the term “production paradigm” to describe the belief that economic growth must be constant and individual worth depends on how efficiently we produce. When that belief governs private life, even leisure becomes accountable to work. An evening must prepare us for tomorrow and pleasure needs a justification beyond the experience itself.
Phillips offers a clear example of the production paradigm colonizing private life: young employees who cling to their jobs because they fear losing them. This is apparently a pervasive phenomenon. These “job-huggers” limit drinking in the evening to protect their work performance the next day because losing their job is a threat to their life prospects. Given their circumstances, that makes sense. Someone worried about paying rent can hardly shrug off a threat to their livelihood.
But notice what happens when this necessary caution becomes a general outlook. The demands of employment begin to determine what counts as a worthwhile private life. We assess an evening with friends partly by its effects on tomorrow’s productivity. Enjoyment incurs a debt that the working self must repay.
That is the production paradigm becoming personal.
Affordability compounds the pressure. Wine competes with necessities, and of course necessities win. Yet economic insecurity can influence more than purchasing power. When the future feels precarious, spending time without an evident payoff can seem as irresponsible as spending money. There is always something useful you could be doing. Eventually, you may stop experiencing this as an external demand. You simply become someone who dislikes “wasting” time.
The earlier dinners and morning dance gatherings Phillips describes might fit this outlook. People can prefer daylight or an early bedtime for perfectly good reasons. Still, socializing before work, with no disruption to the working day, accommodates pleasure to productivity remarkably well. And where pressure to remain employable contributes to withdrawal from friends, wine loses the occasions in which its pleasures become meaningful.
Wine culture is based on quite different norms. At its best, it gives us permission to linger. A bottle changes during dinner and we enjoy leisurely tracking those changes. Conversation wanders without serving a utilitarian purpose. La dolce vita requires accepting that an evening can justify itself.
Phillips’s examples make it plausible to argue that insecurity encourages people to organize pleasure around performance making relaxed enjoyment harder to defend even to themselves. But he doesn’t establish how much of the decline in wine consumption these examples explain. Phillips acknowledges that economic recovery could ease financial constraints. I would give that possibility more weight because improved security might also loosen the habits of self-surveillance that insecurity encourages. Reliable work and affordable housing could make an unhurried dinner feel like a good idea again. The food revolution itself showed how people can turn toward the pleasures of the table when an excessively managed life becomes intolerable.
But there are unfortunately limits to that hope. Smaller generations will remain smaller; there isn’t much we can do about that. And habits acquired under pressure can outlast the pressure. So economic recovery won’t guarantee a return to previous consumption levels. But we should hesitate before treating adaptations to precarity as settled generational preferences.
Wine’s recovery may depend partly on whether young people can afford to enjoy their lives without continually preparing themselves for work.
https://worldoffinewine.com/news-features/wine-cultural-shif
The common factor of several of these trends is economic precarity accompanied by an internalized production paradigm.
Spending less time with friends, anxiety about staying sharp
The uploaded document is a chapter in a book i wrote several years ago about the food revolution. The key concept to focus on there is the “production paradigm.” Much of what I say about food and the production paradigm applies to wine as well.
Read the linked article on the decline in wine consumption and use that as the basis for an argument that the decline in wine consumption especially for young people is at least in part the result of internalizing the production paradigm. Many of the social phenomena discussed in the article seem to be about young people responding to economic precarity by internalizing the idea that only efficiency matters. This is incompatible with wine culture that is about relaxed enjoyment—la dolce vita.
Contrary to the conclusion of the article, there is reason to think this is not a long term trend if economic conditions change.
@humanize-writing
write an article of 600-700 words. Begin with a brief summary of the linked article. then focus on those aspects that can plausibly be explained by the production paradigm and provide the argument.
Close with an assessment of whether these specific factors are likely to be long term trends and with prospects for wine’s recovery.