The Wine Industry’s Alliance with Fascism

trump supportThe American Association of Wine Economists has published a list of the wine industry’s contributions to some of this election cycle’s presidential candidates—including the current occupant of the White House. The above graphic was taken from their twitter feed. It is disturbing to see some of the names on this list. They are active supporters of fascism and white supremacy and will not be seeing any more of my dollars.

There has been a long and inconclusive debate in the philosophy of art about whether the political beliefs and ethical shortcomings of artists damage their work. The great, early-20th century poet Ezra Pound was a fascist. The artist Paul Gaugin abandoned his  family in favor of a series of early teenage wives in Tahiti whom he infected with syphilis. The great Renaissance sculptor Cellini was a murderer and rapist, not to mention the many Hollywood producers and directors who treat women like chattel. The list of good art by bad people is very long.

The question of whether we should engage with their art is a personal one. One might legitimately feel uncomfortable engaging with the work of artists whose conduct is appalling. On the other hand, one doesn’t necessarily perpetuate ideas by consuming them. I doubt I perpetuate child abuse by reading Lolita or fascism by reading Pound’s The Cantos. And if the artists are no longer with us, the money I spend on their art is not contributing to their welfare. If the art is distinctive enough or of sufficient historical importance, it may not be possible to grasp the art of a genre or period without consorting with scum.

None of those factors are in play here. No one needs any of the products on this list. We have an overabundance of great wines to drink and alternative publications to read; we can easily buy something else. And the issues at stake are both current and of the utmost importance.

trump support 2Here is another graphic published by AAWE

I saddens me to discover that the wine industry is so indifferent to the welfare of the country and citizens they depend on for their profits. We need more lists like this to impose economic pain on those who profit off the misery of others–I would add to shame them as well except you cannot shame the shameless.

2 comments

  1. Hi Dwight

    Like you, I was surprised by this report. As I read through the names and addresses, however, I noted that most were NOT from California or Washington…and even fewer were from what we would consider the major wine producing regions of those states. In fact, most of these donations came from people in the distribution and sales side of the wine business, or from producers in states that produce less than 5% of the total wine production of the USA combined.

    I read it through because the conclusions were at odds with my own conversations with so many people in different levels of the wine industry in my area. Both Napa and Sonoma Counties have been democratic strongholds for some time, and it would be surprising to see a large swell of support for Trump from these areas. True, there were a few contributions from my neighbors on the report…I won’t mention any names specifically… but frankly, they fell far short of contributions from such winemaker hot beds as Florida, Indiana, Georgia, etc..

    What is more surprising is that there were not more contributions to Democratic candidates from any part of the sector—and I have to believe that the data somehow doesn’t catch those. There have been fundraisers for some of those candidates in the North Bay, and I know that wine industry leaders have participated in some of them…

  2. Hi Paul,

    Thanks for your perspective on this. The report also does not conform to my experience in talking to people in the industry. But that second chart showing the overall support for Trump was stunning.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.