• About
  • American Foodie: Taste, Art and the Cultural Revolution
  • Mindful Eating 2
  • Our Wine Review Philosophy

Edible Arts

~ Exploring the Aesthetics and Philosophy of Food and Wine

Edible Arts

Tag Archives: wne business

Let’s Be Clear about Influencers in the Wine World

11 Monday Feb 2019

Posted by Dwight Furrow in Wine Culture

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

blogging, Wine Writing, wne business

wine influencerIf you spend much time around marketing types you can’t avoid the term “influencer”. Allegedly , it’s what all of us writers with social media accounts are striving to be. What is an influencer you might ask? Here is one definition from a website called the “influencer marketing hub”:

  • An influencer is an individual who has the power to affect purchase decisions of others because of his/her authority, knowledge, position or relationship with his/her audience.
  • An individual who has a following in a particular niche, which they actively engage with. The size of the following depends on the size of the niche.

So “influence” is specifically about influencing purchasing decisions. This definition is followed by some corporate-speak which is enough to make you gag:

It is important to note that these individuals are not simply marketing tools, but rather social relationship assets with which brands can collaborate to achieve their marketing objectives.

WTF. A “social relationship asset?” A “social relationship asset” that “brands can use to achieve marketing objectives” sounds pretty much like a “marketing tool”. We can shorten this to just “tool”—that is what you are if you’re an “influencer”. Marketers seem to think that people who write and post on social media have nothing better to do than promote their products. I can only speak for myself but I don’t want to be anyone’s “asset”.

I seriously doubt that, in the wine world, bloggers, tweeters and Instagrammers are influencers as defined here. Former wine retailer Amber Lebeau wrote a post about this recently and I think she’s exactly right:

In over seven years working on the floor, I’ve never had a customer come in with a blog post, Instagram or tweet on their phone looking for a wine. Again, anecdotal, but that is the stark truth.

Amber goes on to list several types of people who do influence purchase decisions—friends and family, somms and restaurant by-the-glass programs, visits to wineries, and published media among others. Among writers, the large circulation wine magazines such as Wine Spectator and newsletters such as the Wine Advocate or Jancis Robinson’s Purple Pages apparently have some influence. But this is a very small group whose words actually induce people to make specific purchases. The rest of us are doing something else.

The problem here is a conceptual problem. The concept of an “influencer” tries to shoehorn something as complex and multifaceted as human communication into a narrowly focused activity with a clear, instrumental payoff such as a “purchasing decision”. Wine writers, bloggers, Twitter publishers, and Instagrammers are first and foremost communicators. What they do is create discourse. They transmit information of all sorts, entertain, instruct, mark discoveries, give commands, cajole, mimic or confuse. They articulate, reinforce or undermine values, and most importantly, they establish connections, passageways that people can use to conduct life.

All of this communication is about influence of some sort—it changes minds, provokes emotion, motivates action. Purchasing decisions are only a very small part of this.

We create discourse because communities need communication to survive and individuals need connections to be, well, connected.  As writers we aren’t assets for individual wineries but web spinners and mesh makers, establishing connections, showing relationships, forging alliances, creating concepts of good and bad. It’s about establishing the background conditions that allow some wines to emerge as desirable.

If you want a handy marketing term to hang this on then think of it as creating “buzz”—a time worn term but still accurate.If no one is talking about your wine then it’s unlikely to be successful.

Once you instrumentalize this important work and reduce it to a purchase decision it no longer functions effectively as communication and begins to lose its community function. It’s purpose is directed away from its core function. Communication and the maintenance of discourse is not something that can be easily measured and thus will never appear to be cost effective. To insist that it must is to measure it according to a standard it cannot meet which will destroy it.

If you want a vibrant wine community we should put this concept of “influencer” in its proper place.

Advertisements

Search

Join the Food Revolution

American Foodie: Taste, Art, and Cultural Revolution

Get Our Guide to Wine Tasting in San Diego

Wine Guide to San Diego at Amazon

Categories

  • 3 Quarks Daily Column
  • Amuse Bouche
  • Aphorisms
  • Art and Food
  • Art and Wine
  • Contemporary Food Culture
  • Daily Blog Summary
  • Edible Art
  • Food History
  • Food Science
  • General Aesthetics
  • Monthly Newsletters
  • Philosophy
  • Philosophy of Food and Wine
  • Recipes
    • Appetizer
    • Bread
    • Dessert
    • Lunch
    • Main Dish
    • Salad
    • Side Dish
    • Soup
  • Restaurant Reviews
  • Roving Decanter Posts
  • San Diego Wine Events
  • San Diego Wines
  • The Art of Wine
  • The Creative Kitchen
  • The Ethics of Eating
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • Wine Culture
  • Wine Reviews
    • Ageing Report
    • Budget Wines
  • Winemaker Interviews
  • RSS - Posts
  • RSS - Comments

Visit Us On Facebook

Edible Arts

Promote Your Page Too

Like Us On Facebook

Like Us On Facebook

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Blogroll

  • Contemporary Aesthetics
  • egullet
  • Fermentation
  • Ideas in Food
  • Jamie Goode
  • Leite's Culinaria
  • Mindful Eating 2
  • Orangette
  • San Diego Wine and Food
  • Serious Eats
  • Smitten Kitchen
  • The Curious Cook
  • The Philosophy of Food Project
  • The Wine Elite
  • Vinography
  • Zester Daily

aesthetics aesthetics of food aesthetics of food and wine aesthetics of wine Aphorisms Argentinian wine art and food Art and wine Australian Wines blogging Bordeaux Cabernet Franc Cabernet Sauvignon California wine California Wines Chardonnay Chianti Chilean Wine Columbia Valley creativity fine dining food aesthetics food and emotions food and identity food and wine aesthetics food business French wine Italian Wine Italian Wines locavorism Malbec Matt Kramer merlot Monterey County Napa Wines natural wine objectivity objectivity and taste oregon wines Paso Robles Philosophy of food Philosophy of food and wine philosophy of wine pinot noir Red blend Red blends restaurants Rhone Blends Riesling San Diego Wines Sangiovese Santa Barbara Wines Sauvignon Blanc Sonoma Wines Spanish Wine Spanish Wines Sparkling wine Steve Heimoff Syrah Tempranillo terroir Washington State Wines Willamette Valley wine aesthetics wine and art wine and emotions wine blogs wine business wine criticism wine evaluation wine news wine science wine tasting Wine Writing zinfandel

Networked Blogs

NetworkedBlogs
Blog:
Edible Arts
Topics:
Food, Aesthetics, Wine
 
Follow my blog
Advertisements

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy